The anime industry has long been on the horns of a dilemma: Pursue artistic innovation, or bow to commercial pressures?
And the latest move by the Japanese government to combat piracy with A.I. could change anime’s trajectory.
With $2 million allocated to develop an A.I.-powered system that tracks and removes pirated content, this ambitious effort aims to protect intellectual property.
But what does this mean for an industry already grappling with cultural shifts and artistic decline?
The A.I. system proposed by Japan’s Agency for Cultural Affairs will analyze pirated sites’ layouts and advertisements. Then it will cross-reference them with official images provided by publishers. This automation promises to reduce the time and cost associated with manual copyright enforcement.
This initiative follows similar approaches, like Webtoon embedding invisible data to trace leaks and Aniplex’s use of watermarked TV episodes to identify suspected pirates.
Related: A.I. Books: The Death of the Author?
While these measures aim to curtail piracy, they also raise concerns about false positives. What happens when innocent websites and viewers get flagged for copyright infringement? Such missteps could alienate fans who support anime through legitimate channels, diminishing goodwill in an already fractious global fanbase.
This technological crackdown comes at a pivotal moment for anime. Since the late 1990s, the industry has drifted away from taking creative risks, character-driven design, and rich storytelling to a more homogenized and overproduced product. A glut of series chasing trends like slice-of-life and cute girls doing cute things has diluted quality, leaving fewer standout works amid the disposable dross.
Related: Anime Ground Zero
For many old school fans, anime’s transition from hand-painted cels to digital animation marked the beginning of a decline. Digital techniques trade depth and texture for efficiency, leading to flatter visuals and less emotive character designs. As Gen Y nostalgia rekindles longing for anime’s golden years, the industry must learn how to balance technological progress and artistic integrity.
Speaking of integrity, using A.I. to police piracy may indeed offer short-term gains. IP owners stand to see increased profits thanks to potential reductions in illegal streaming.
On the other hand, the move could exacerbate existing issues in the industry.
- Restricting access: Fan translations and informal sharing have historically been gateways for international fans to discover anime. Over-policing could stifle this organic growth
- Creative risks: A crackdown on piracy may lead studios to double down on safe content, reducing the incentive to innovate. And myopic focus on mainstream profitability could worsen the industry’s reliance on cookie-cutter designs and predictable plots
- Fan alienation: Overzealous takedowns could harm anime’s global appeal. Fans who feel targeted or restricted may transfer their loyalty to other forms of entertainment.
Anime’s ongoing struggle to reconcile its past, present, and future reflects a broader cultural tension. Efforts like the A.I. anti-piracy system highlight how technological advancements can preserve and distort art forms. If mismanaged, the initiative risks reinforcing the perception that anime has strayed too far from its artistic roots.
Related: How JRPGs Made Anime Mainstream in the West
In the book industry, best selling author Joe Konrath always said that the way to fight piracy isn’t with ever-tighter crackdowns. It’s with pricing and convenience.
Likewise, the anime industry must address the underlying causes of piracy, such as high prices, regional restrictions, and delayed releases. Offering affordable and timely global access to movies and series may prove a more sustainable solution than relying on A.I. enforcement alone.
In the end, whether this development serves as a lifeline or a noose for anime depends on the industry’s ability to balance protection with accessibility; artistry with commerce. Fans and creators alike will be watching—and adapting—as the story unfolds.
Get early looks at my works in progress, the chance to influence my writing, and VIP access to my exclusive Discord.
Sign up at Patreon or SubscribeStar now.
Thrill to the best dark, not bleak, fantasy
Quest with relatable heroes against overwhelming odds
A few thoughts on this:
1) Despite the generations length of piracy, anime has still grown to be a worldwide sensation with the financial earnings to back it up. I think this will be an uphill battle for Japan.
2) Cracking down on piracy could also damage the preservation of the medium – I draw a parallel to Nintendo’s hate for ROM hackers. Truth of the matter is, the ROM hackers kept many of their old titles relevant because it was easy to play great games no longer in print. You could avoid the scalpers, enjoy what was made, and keep the conversation going about said title in the greater culture. Same logic could apply here with some anime that is no longer in print, out of cycle on sites like Crunchyroll or is behind a paywall on crappy sites like Crunchyroll.
3) Depending on how the AI scrapes the internet for pirated content, there could be around that. Presuming AI tries to visually look for copyrighted stuff, pirating sites can find a way to incorporate Glaze/Nightshade. It’s an anti AI scraping technology developed by the Univ. of Chicago a while back. It creates a subtle amount of noise to protect images from being scraped by AI that attempts to use it for learning purposes. When the AI “sees” an image protected by Nightshade, it’s all distorted. Toss that over a video or a web page and the AI will be blind.
Streaming is definitely bad for preservation. We’ve already seen streaming sites engage in censorship, probably most infamously when many sites got rid of any episodes that even hinted at blackface. But the bulk of the loss occurs when people just don’t care.
For example, Sony owned both Funimation and Crunchyroll. Then it merged them. Funimation had its own streaming service, not only having the rights to show the videos but the videos themselves all set up. But when the services were merged these videos were not transferred over presumably because it would require some form of effort. Thus shows like Tenchi Universe cannot legally be watched anywhere online though luckily in that case there are still plentiful (but out of print) physical versions.
As time goes by you will get more and more of shows vanishing just because people aren’t willing to do even the basic maintenance of setting up a new page for the videos. Now piracy does not have to be the answer, but Japanese companies don’t show any signs of wanting to make physical media easily available outside of Japan.
I also suspect that we are going to see something similar to what’s going on with video games. Yesterday Blizzard announced that Warcraft 1 and 2 will be removed from sale everywhere, even though they do not have to maintain them. This is because they are making “remastered” versions of the games and they want to erase the memories of the originals. With so many anime getting remade, it wouldn’t surprise me if companies started pulling down the original series to force fans to watch the new one instead (and perhaps more importantly, rob fans of the ability to compare the two and determine if there was a point to remaking the series in the first place.)
Ah yes the cute girl anime, that’s the problem. Lmao.
Otaku rule this fucking medium. Get out.