The highly anticipated Sad Puppies 4 recommended reading list has been released. Just in the nick of time for Hugo Award nominations, which close at the end of this month, these works were suggested by SF fans from around the world and across the web.
The full list can be found here.
Suggestions were completely open to the public, and SP4 even received signal boosts from genre heavyweights who’ve taken issue with past Puppy campaigns, like Mike Glyer and George R. R. Martin. These factors support the view of SP4’s recommendations as a representative sample of broader SF fandom’s tastes.
Sad Puppies 4 gave the fans a chance to speak. What did they say? If the most-suggested works are any indication, SP4 voters made a statement that echoes what folks like Larry Correia, Sarah Hoyt, and Tom Simon have been saying for a while, now.
The Superversive Mandate
I’ve written previously on the Superversive literary movement.
A quick recap for those who are just joining us: the Superversive movement seeks to return SFF to the service of beauty, truth, and the good–a service which the curators of literature in NY publishing have not only abandoned, but betrayed. Tom Simon in particular has called for overturning the gatekeepers’ subversion of SF, not from below, but from above, i.e. superversion.
Judging by SP4 participants’ choices, most of them are sympathetic to Tom’s vision. So many recommended works contain superversive elements, or were written by authors affiliated with the movement, that it’s no exaggeration to say that Sad Puppies 4 represents a superversive mandate.
The old guard’s open contempt for 70% of their audience may have contributed to the backlash. |
SP4 List Highlights
Here are highly placed entries from the official recommendations list that contain superversive themes, were written by superversive authors, or both.
- Best Novel: Somewhither, Honor at Stake, The Aeronaut’s Windlass, A Long Time Until Now, Son of the Black Sword, Nethereal
- Campbell Award for Best New Writer: Andy Weir, Brian Niemeier
- Best Short Story: Tuesdays with Molakesh the Destroyer
- Best Related Work: Sad Puppies Bite Back, Appendix N, Legosity
- Best Dramatic Presentation – Long: The Martian
- Best Dramatic Presentation – Short: Daredevil, Season 1, episodes 2 and 13
- Best Editor – Long Form: Toni Weisskopf, Jim Mintz, Tony Daniel
- Best Editor – Short Form: Jason Rennie
- Best Fan Writer: Jeffro Johnson, Declan Finn, Dave Freer, John C. Wright, Peter Grant, Tom Simon
- Best Fancast: Geek Gab, The Rageaholic
- Best Fanzine: Superversive SF, According to Hoyt, Bayou Renaissance Man, Declan Finn, Mad Genius Club
- Best Semiprozine: Sci Phi Journal
Obligatory reminder of author’s well-received book for sale. |
Obligatory reminder that the well-received book has an even better sequel. (Eligible next year.) |
Update: in the time since this article was first written, my name has also been added to the Rabid Puppies list of Campbell nominees. The Supreme Dark Lord is indeed kind.
Bravo. Well done, by you and by everybody else. There's been a sort of "shadow fandom" for years now, and the noise made by SP3 last year broke it all into the open. Suddenly I have new friends, new writers to read, new ways to publish, and new online communities to be part of. All that talk last year about how the Sad Puppies lost (for various silly reasons) is absurd. The movement is about a great deal more than just awards.
Now, I still think that subversion (i.e., overturning from below) can be useful, especially if you steal some of the floorboards from the APs' usual haunts. A few of them will then doubtless fall into the cellar and break something.
Congrats, man!
Thanks! I hope to see both of you on the list next year.
*Ten Gentle Opportunities* will be eligible next year. We'll see if I can fight the turbulence enough to finish something else…
Everybody got that? Good. The book is here:
http://www.amazon.com/Ten-Gentle-Opportunities-Jeff-Duntemann-ebook/dp/B01AQ1549E/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1458537492&sr=1-1&keywords=ten+gentle+opportunities
Get to it!
Also, you're on the Rabid Puppies list for Campbell. Not, alas, for Best Novel.
http://voxday.blogspot.com/2016/03/rabid-puppies-2016-list.html
Thanks for mentioning that. Nethereal may not have made the RPs' cut for best novel, but I'm grateful for the Campbell nod.
On a related note: I can't wait to lose to Andy Weir!
Next year you'll still be in the running. We'll go for that!
We will indeed.
Oh yeah.
All of us 😉